Thursday, April 28, 2011

My Review of "Eat, Pray, Love"

Don't bother. Watch Band of Brothers instead.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Mr. Knightly Has Been Demoted

I like movies. Who doesn't like movies? There's something out there for pretty much everyone to enjoy - from a good comedy to a gut-wrenching drama to an exciting action flick, and so on.

I like a somewhat wide variety of movies, but one thing I always look for is a character that I find inspiring in some way. And generally, I'm looking for a male character, there's just something great about a humble, strong male lead, and, let's face it, I'm a girl. I'm attracted to men. There also aren't all that many male leads in movies who are truly inspiring in almost every way. The number one slot* is, and probably will remain, Father Gabriel from "The Mission." The humble priest's willingness to sacrifice himself for the sake of spreading the Gospel is so moving, and his refusal to leave the people he loves in order to remain safe, ultimately giving his life with them, is incredible. The number two slot has been for quite some time the quite wonderful Mr. Knightly from "Emma." I love how he is never ok with Emma doing something wrong and getting away with it, he rebukes her more than once. He always treats everyone with respect, no matter who they are or how they act.
But then this last weekend I started watching Band of Brothers**, and there is just something about Maj. Dick Winters. Humility and strength describe him to a T, he just exudes a quiet confidence, feeling no need to try to impress anyone with bluster or carousing. He sticks to his code of morality unwaveringly, bravely goes before his men into combat, and feels deeply for each of them.
There's a quote in the first episode that really struck me early on, showing his character, as he is talking to his new 1st Lt. Buck Compton:

Winters: These men have been through the toughest training the Army has to offer, under the worst possible circumstances, and they volunteered for it.
Compton: Criminy, Dick, I was just shooting craps with them.
Winters: You know why they volunteered? Because they knew that the man in the foxhole next to them would be the best, not some draftee who's going to get them killed.
Compton: Are you ticked because they like me? Because I'm spending time to get to know my soldiers? I mean, c'mon, you've been with them for two years? I've been here for six days.
Winters: You were gambling, Buck.
Compton: So what? Soldiers do that. I don't deserve a reprimand for it.
Winters: What if you'd won?
Compton: What?
Winters: What if you'd won? Don't ever put yourself in the position where you can take from these men.

And so poor Knightly, while of course still quite wonderful, is now number three. I don't think a Jane Austen hero could be above Major Winters, an actual person, in my mind.


*Some may wonder why this isn't Christ in one of the many movies about His life. OF COURSE He is the most inspirational person there is, but I don't particularly like movies about Him. Somehow they never seem quite right, as though only the Bible can ever tell it correctly.

**Please note that while there is so much to be admired about "Band of Brothers," there is also a fair amount of foul language (inluding many F-words and using the Lord's name in vain) which certainly bothered me. There's also a good amount a violence, but really, if you're gonna watch a war movie, you kinda gotta expect that. Unfortunately at the beginning of Episode 9 there is a short sex scene, which I totally missed when I watched through it. I did get up to grab some water at the beginning of that episode I remember so that must've been when it happened. Otherwise, it's clean in that respect. I don't understand why they have to throw those in, it's quite bothersome.